
Information and Guidance on the
Americans with Disabilities Act
Spring 1997 Vol.1, No.2
This issue highlights resources and information on outdoor
recreation
What's Inside?
Employment Update
Access Board News
Guest Editorial
DOJ Update
Design Solutions
Building Your Rolodex
Regional News
Great Web Sites
Frequently Asked Questions
Publications
Events
EMPLOYMENT
UPDATE
Application for Disability Benefits Does Not Bar Claim
Under ADA
The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC)
recently advised that representations made in connection with an
application for disability benefits should not be an automatic
bar to a claim under Title I of the Americans with Disabilities
Act (ADA). The Commission clarified its position by issuing
Enforcement Guidance on the Effect of Representations Made in
Applications for Disability Benefits on the Determination of
Whether a Person Is a "Qualified Individual with a
Disability" Under the ADA.
EEOC Chairman Gilbert F. Casellas said, "The guidance
addresses a significant and recurring issue on which the
Commission has filed several amicus briefs. It clarifies why a
person may be able to meet the eligibility requirements for
disability benefits and still be a 'qualified individual with a
disability' for ADA purposes."
The guidance explains that the ADA's purposes and standards
are fundamentally different from those of other disability
benefits programs such as social security, workers' compensation,
and disability insurance. Because of these differences, the
guidance explains, representations made in connection with an
application for benefits may be relevant to, but not
determinative of, whether a person is a "qualified
individual with a disability" under the ADA. The guidance
emphasizes that, when assessing whether a person who has applied
for disability benefits is a "qualified individual with a
disability," it is crucial to consider all the relevant
evidence. The guidance further explains that public policy
supports the conclusion that representations made in other
contexts about the ability to work should not be an absolute bar
to bringing an ADA claim.
Jury awards $300,000 to Former Police Officer in
Reassignment Case
The Department of Justice won a $300,000 jury award on behalf
of Jack Davoll, a former Denver police officer injured in the
line of duty, because Denver refused to reassign Davoll to a
vacant job that he was qualified to perform-such as criminal
investigator or probation officer. The jury also found that
Denver had failed to show that changing its policy to allow
reassignment would impose an "undue hardship" on the
City. The Denver Police Department had forced Davoll to retire
after three incidents that left him with injuries to his back,
neck, and shoulder.
The monetary award compensates Davoll for emotional distress
and pain and suffering. The judge will later decide to which job
Mr. Davoll is entitled, and he will determine the amount of back
pay that Davoll will receive. The court ruled before the trial in
United States v. City and County of Denver that the ADA's
requirement to make "reasonable accommodation" to
employees' disabilities includes reassignment to vacant positions
and imposes a duty on employers to consider reassignment. The
court also found that Denver's policy of barring the reassignment
of police officers with disabilities to vacant "career
service" positions for which they were qualified violated
the ADA.
The jury's verdict followed a seven-day trial in two
consolidated cases. In addition to the case brought by the United
States, three private plaintiffs, including Mr. Davoll, filed an
action challenging the Police Department's refusal to reassign
them to career service positions after they became disabled. Paul
Escobedo and Deborah Clair were each awarded $250,000 in
compensatory damages in the private suit.
For a copy of the latest EEOC guidance or this excerpt from
"Enforcing The ADA..." call our Center at 800-949-4232
V/TTY. Or, link to the EEOC's or DOJ's web site from ours at www.adaptiveenvironments.org
Back to top
NEWS FROM
THE ACCESS BOARD
Telecommunications Access, Revised ADAAG, Play Facilities
Access in Process
Recommendations for guidelines that would assure that
telecommunications equipment be "designed, developed and
fabricated to be accessible to and usable by people with
disabilities, if readily achievable" were presented to the
Access Board in January by the Telecommunications Access Advisory
Board. The new Telecommunications Act gives the Access Board
responsibility to produce guidelines by August 1, 1997. The
report is available on the Internet, at www.access_board.gov or by
calling the Access Board at 202-272-5434 Voice, or 202-272-5449
TTY, request publication S-32.
ADAAG Revision:
The Board continues its work reviewing and discussing the
Recommendations for a New ADAAG. The intent is that "the
guidelines remain state of the art, be in harmony with model
building codes and standards... and continue to meet the needs of
people with disabilities". The Board plans to vote on a
proposed rule to update the ADA Accessibility Guidelines by
January 1998.
Play Facilities Guidelines:
The Regulatory Negotiation Committee on Accessibility
Guidelines for Play Facilities met January 6 - 9 in Berkeley,
California, continuing their negotiations on the scoping
provisions for newly constructed and altered play facilities
covered by the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). While no
final decisions have been made, committee members reached
preliminary agreement on the following issues:
Access to Ground Level Play Activities: At least
one of each type of play activity on the ground level would have
to be accessible.
Access to Elevated Play Activities: At least 50
percent of elevated play components should be accessible. Play
activities are considered elevated only when they are part of a
composite structure. For example, a stand-alone slide would not
be considered an "elevated" component. Where elevated
play components are provided, the number of accessible ground
level activities would have to be equal to 50 percent or more of
the total number of elevated components. Such accessible ground
level activities could be used to satisfy the ground level
"one of each type" requirement. Where ramp access is
provided to all elevated play components, no additional ground
level activities would be required.
Access to Soft Contained Play Activities: The
committee agreed in concept that access would be required to
enter and exit a soft contained play system through either a
transfer system or a ramp. Ramp access, however, would not be
required within the system itself.
The play facilities regulatory negotiation committee was
convened by the Access Board in February 1996, and held its first
meeting in March. Using a rulemaking process that Board Chair
Judy Heumann has called "public involvement to the greatest
extent," this committee was charged with developing the
actual proposed rule for accessibility guidelines that will apply
to all newly constructed and altered play facilities covered by
the ADA. In addition to the committee's 17 member organizations,
a large number of other people from the public have participated
in the process, providing public comment and joining in committee
and working group discussions.
The Board expects to publish the proposed rule developed by
this committee some time this summer. At that time, the public
will be invited to submit written comments to the Board for
consideration as the final rule is being drafted.
Rulemaking Update
The following is a summary of some of the Board's current
activities, which includes, wherever possible, anticipated dates
for an Access Board vote on proposed or final rules. It should be
noted that following a Board vote, each rule must go to the
Office of Management and Budget for review, and then-in the case
of ADA-related rules-to the Department of Justice. Only once a
final rule is adopted by the Department of Justice is it
enforceable under the ADA.
Outdoor Developed Areas: The Board intends to
use regulatory negotiation to develop a proposed rule for access
to outdoor developed areas, which include hiking and walking
trails, campgrounds, and the similar areas. Next Step: The Board
plans to issue a notice of intent to form a regulatory
negotiation committee later this month.
Places of Amusement, Boating and Fishing Facilities,
Golf, and Sports Facilities: After receiving the Advisory
committee's report in May 1994, the Board published it as an
advance notice of proposed rulemaking. The Board is drafting
proposed guidelines for places of amusement, boating and fishing
facilities, golf, and sports facilities based on the
recommendations of the advisory committee, public comments
received in response to the advance notice of proposed rulemaking
and follow up meetings. Next Step: The Board plans to vote on a
proposed rule in 1998.
Water Transportation: This rulemaking will
address access to ferries, cruise ships, excursion boats, and
other vessels. Research was completed in July 1996 and provided
valuable information for future rulemaking. The Board and the
Department of Transportation held an information meeting with
organizations representing people with disabilities and the
marine industry to determine the scope and complexity of the
rulemaking. The next steps in this rulemaking have not been
determined.
Back to top
GUEST EDITORIAL
The Americans with Disabilities Act and Outdoor Recreation
Despite the fact that the Americans with Disabilities Act
(ADA) has been law for more than six years, there are still
accessibility challenges and confusion with respect to parks and
outdoor recreation. Since its passage in July 1990, the 49
million Americans who benefit from this civil rights law, and the
people responding to the ADA, have been learning and occasionally
stumbling through its interpretation and application.
The Dilemma and the Opportunity
Accessibility issues frequently pose a major dilemma for park
(and all recreation) professionals. The problem is that managers
are responsible and liable for a host of accessibility
challenges. There are two topics at issue. One is the Americans
with Disabilities Act. The other is a host of accessibility
regulations and guidelines. Both of these matter, but they are
different and should not be confused. The ADA is a civil rights
law. Accessibility regulations are just that-regulations.
Recreation facilities and programs are subject to both.
The Rules Are Changing and Standards and Guidelines Are
Evolving!
Accessibility requirements are being defined in two
areas-court decisions and administrative rules. Court decisions
are one basis for defining what actions you will need to take to
minimize accessibility liability. Regulations are also evolving,
especially those that affect outdoor recreation and developed
areas. Do not count on "existing condition" or
"grandfathering" protections. The ADA does require you
to provide access for pre-existing programs and facilities even
if standards for those facilities do not exist. Efforts are
underway to finalize recreation facility standards, and it is
suggested that the Recommendations for Accessibility Guidelines:
Recreational Facilities and Outdoor Developed Areas, developed by
a national advisory committee be utilized until final standards
are available. These guidelines are very comprehensive but will
probably not be finalized until sometime in 1997. Utilizing them
now, along with a lot of common sense, will go a long way in
providing accessibility and will significantly decrease the
possibility of being in violation of the law.
When Must You Take Action to Conform to the Accessibility
Requirement?
Here are some examples of situations when you must take
actions to conform to the accessibility requirements.
New Construction
All new facilities including recreation facilities must be
accessible. All elements of buildings, parking and site must
comply fully with existing ADA Design Guidelines (ADAAG),
published July 1991, or other applicable codes. All elements
covered under the draft Outdoor Recreation Design Guidelines are
to be accessible, utilizing the best information available. At
this point in time, the best information available is found in
the National Advisory Committee recommendations and related
documents.
When Remodeling
When remodeling occurs, those areas being remodeled must comply
fully with the appropriate standards and guidelines, when
technically feasible and when the design solutions do not
significantly alter the experience.
Any time You Offer Programs and Service to the Public
If you offer programs or service to the public, they must be
accessible to everyone. Some kinds of programs are relatively
simple to make accessible. For example, you must provide
accessible picnic tables, camp sites and trails. Not all table
and sites need to be accessible, but a reasonable percentage must
be. Some programs are inherently fraught with challenges. Even
donkey tours of the Grand Canyon and whitewater rafting programs
have to be accessible, as long as they can be made so without
" undue financial burden," without "changing the
fundamental nature of the activity" and the disabled
participant is deemed to be "an otherwise qualified
individual."
In situations where access cannot be provided, alternative
ways of providing program access are sometimes permissible. For
example, a recycling program in southern Minnesota offered public
tours of its facility. When accessibility became an issue, and
the required modifications were considered extreme, the agency
stopped offering public tours. In contrast, another recycling
center continued its public tours and made them accessible. Some
parts of the tour were difficult to make accessible. Those areas
were made accessible through videotape presentation and by using
mirrors that were strategically located with viewing windows.
Agencies do have options regarding how the programs will be made
accessible. Consulting with representatives of groups of people
with disabilities and with technical experts will assist in
choosing the best and most cost-effective option.
Excerpted from "The Americans with Disabilities Act
and Public Recreation: Fact, Fiction and Common Sense" by
Julee Quarve-Peterson. Reprinted from "TRENDS," Vol.33,
no. 1, 1996. "TRENDS" is cooperatively produced by the
National Park Service and the National Recreation and Park
Association (NRPA), a private, nonprofit organization. Copies can
be purchased from the NRPA for $8.00 per issue. Call
703-578-5564.
Back to top
DOJ
ENFORCEMENT UPDATE
Recent Decisions from the U.S. Department of Justice
NCAA is Covered by Title III
The U.S. District Court for the Western District of Washington
ordered the National Collegiate Athletic Association to allow the
University of Washington to continue to provide an athletic
scholarship to Toure Butler, a college freshman with a learning
disability who is a member of the University of Washington
football team. Butler claims that the NCAA rules regarding high
school courses and test scores discriminate against him because
of his learning disability, and that reasonable modifications in
policy should be made to grant him eligibility. The Department
filed an amicus brief in Butler v. National Collegiate Athletic
Association arguing that the NCAA is covered by Title III,
because the NCAA is a private entity that "operates"
places of public accommodation such as athletic training
facilities and stadiums. The court agreed with the Department's
position on coverage and issued a preliminary injunction.
Court Orders Line of Sight Over Standing Spectators
A Federal court in Washington, D.C., ruled, after trial in
Paralyzed Veterans of America v. Ellerbe Becket Architects and
Engineers, P.C., that the designs for the MCI Center, a new
indoor basketball and hockey arena under construction in downtown
Washington, violate the ADA's architectural requirements for
newly constructed facilities. The court earlier held, as the
Department argued in an amicus brief, that the requirement that
wheelchair users have lines of sight to the arena floor that are
comparable to those for other spectators means that wheelchair
users must be able to see over other spectators when those
spectators stand up. In reaching this conclusion, the court
deferred to the Department's long-held position that wheelchair
seating locations must provide wheelchair users with such lines
of sight over standing spectators. After trial, the court ruled
that the wheelchair seating locations were not adequately
distributed throughout the different categories of seating-there
were too many wheelchair locations in the end zones, and too few
along the sides of the court or ice. The court gave the arena
owner 30 days to submit a new design for the seating bowl. The
case is now on appeal.
Formal Settlement Agreement is Reached Concerning Effective
Communication
The police department of North Kingston, Rhode Island, agreed
to adopt a formal written policy ensuring effective communication
in situations involving contact between officers and members of
the public who are deaf or hard of hearing. The settlement
agreement resolved a complaint alleging that the police
department failed to interview a deaf individual who witnessed a
fatal automobile accident.
Formal Settlement Agreement in Title II Historic Building
The Department of Justice signed an agreement with the State
of Massachusetts providing for access to Doric Hall, located in
the eighteenth century section of the Massachusetts State House
in Boston. Doric Hall is currently inaccessible to individuals
with mobility impairments because of five steps. The settlement
agreement provides for alterations to Doric Hall, including the
installation of a lift. Until the alterations are completed, the
State has agreed to implement a policy requiring all services
currently in an inaccessible location to be relocated, upon
request, to an accessible area of the State House.
DOJ Resolves Cases Through Informal Settlements
* Title II: A county supervisor of elections in Florida
agreed to resurface a parking lot, sidewalk, and entrance to a
polling facility to make it more accessible.
* A midwestern State department of corrections agreed to
provide Brailled materials and a Braille typewriter to an inmate
with impaired vision.
* Title III: A small-town restaurant in upstate New
York modified its policies to allow patrons who use service
animals access to the restaurant, and also removed architectural
barriers in the parking lot.
The above material is excerpted from "Enforcing the
ADA, A Status Report from the Department of Justice (October -
December 1996)." Call our Center for a copy of the full
report: 800-949-4232 V/TTY or download from the DOJ Home Page,
linked to www.adaptiveenvironments.org
**And, from a recent DOJ press
release...
Festival to Become More Accessible to People With
Disabilities
Washington, D.C.
Under a recent agreement reached with the Department of Justice,
Mid-America Festivals, the operator of the Minnesota Renaissance
Festival, will make its facilities more accessible for persons
with disabilities. The festival, which is the largest of its kind
in the country, features a variety of entertainment, art and
crafts vendors, and food specialties from Renaissance Europe. The
settlement resolves a complaint filed under the ADA by a
Wisconsin man who uses a wheelchair. He alleged that he was
unable to visit many of the shops and booths at the festival
because they were not accessible, and that some shops had ramps
that were dangerously steep. Under the agreement, Mid-America
Festivals will lower ticket booths and food counters, maintain an
accessible prepared path to the entrance and exit of the
facility, provide accessible portable restroom facilities and
telephones, ensure that all barriers to access are removed from
independently owned shops where readily achievable, and pay civil
penalties to the government. The Festival operators have already
implemented many of these changes for the 1996 festival as a
result of the Department's investigation.
For a copy of the press release call the DOJ's ADA
Information Line at 800-514-0301 Voice or 800-514-0383 TTY or,
access the DOJ's ADA home page by hot linking from our web site
at www.adaptiveenvironments.org
Back to top
ADA DESIGN
SOLUTIONS
Readily Accessible Barrier Removal: Van Accessible Parking
Spaces
Public accommodations must remove architectural barriers that
are structural in nature in existing facilities when it is
"readily achievable" to do so. Readily achievable means
easily accomplishable and able to be carried out without much
difficulty or expense.
If readily achievable, the first accessible parking space that
is provided as part of barrier removal activities should be a van
accessible space. This type of parking space can be used by both
vans and by cars and makes it possible for people using
wheelchairs and lift equipped vans to safely enter and exit their
vehicles.
Examples of barrier removal related to accessible parking may
include restriping a section or sections of a parking lot to
provide accessible parking spaces with designated access aisles,
installing signs that designate accessible parking spaces to the
building entrance, and providing a marked crossing where the
accessible route crosses a vehicular way. Where parking lot
surfaces slope more than 1:50, select the most nearly level area
that is available for the accessible parking spaces. When
selecting the area for the accessible parking spaces, consider
the location of the accessible route that must connect the access
aisle to the facility's accessible entrance(s).
This material is excerpted from ADA TA: Technical
Assistance Updates from the US Department of Justice. This
illustrated booklet provides practical information on how to
comply with the ADA. Available by calling us at 800-949-4232
V/TTY.
Back to top
BUILDING YOUR
ROLODEX
National Center on Accessibility
Provides training, technical assistance, publications and
research studies in the areas of parks and recreation.
800-424-1877 Voice and TTY, www.indiana.edu/~nca/
National Park Service (NPS) Accessibility Office:
Resource center for technical data and design work concerning
accessibility. 202-343-7040. For general information and for
phone numbers of individual park sites, 617-242-5667, www.nps.gov
National Recreation and Park Association (NRPA)
In a cooperative effort with the NPS the NRPA produces three
quarterly publications, "Trends", "Grist" and
"Design", all of which occasionally feature articles on
accessible park design and structures. 703-820-4940
U.S. Department of Transportation (DOT)
Offers technical assistance on ADA provisions applying to public
transportation. Documents and questions, 202-366-1656 Voice.
202-366-4567 TTY. Complaints and enforcement, 202-366-2285 Voice.
202-366-0153 TTY. www.fta.dot.gov
Federal Communications Commission (FCC)
Offers technical assistance on ADA telephone relay service
requirements. Documents and questions, 202-418-0190 Voice.
202-418-2555 TTY. Complaints and enforcement, 202-632-7553 Voice.
202-632-0845 TTY. For information about the Telecommunications
Act of 1996 visit www.fcc.gov
Back to top
NEWS FROM AROUND
THE REGION
New England ADA & Accessible IT Center Contracts with Six States
The New England ADA & Accessible IT Center has contracted
with the following organizations in each New England state to act
as "state affiliates" for the purpose of providing
information and training to the business, government, nonprofit,
and disability communities and to support voluntary compliance
with the Americans with Disabilities Act. Anyone in New England
who has questions about their rights or responsibilities under
the ADA can call us toll-free at 800-949-4232 (V/TTY) or call one
of the affiliates who are state experts for specialized
assistance.
ADA Coalition of Connecticut
P.O. Box 524 Stratford, CT 06497-0524 Suzanne Liquerman
860-297-4383 Voice 860-566-2102 TTY suzanne.liquerman@po.state.ct.us
Maine Advocacy Services
P.O. Box 2007 Augusta, ME 04338 Jim McGurty 207-626-2774 x118
V/TTY advocate@mint.net
Massachusetts Office on Disability
1 Ashburton Place Boston, MA 02108 Lorraine Greiff 617-727-7440
V/TTY 800-322-2020 (MA only) lgreiff@state.ma.us
NH Governor's Commission on Disability
57 Regional Drive Concord, N.H. 03301 Mike Jenkins 603-271-2773
V/TTY m_jenkin@tec.NH.US
RI Governor's Commission on the Handicapped
555 Valley Street Providence, RI 02908-5686 Albert Tardie
401-277-3731 V/TTY ri.able.too@juno.com
Vermont Center for Independent Living
11 East State Street Montpelier, VT 05602 Susan Reid 802-229-0501
V/TTY vcil@plainfield.bypass.com
Maine Design Professionals and Code Officials Attend ADA/
Life Safety Workshops
More than two hundred architects, design professionals and
code enforcement officials from across Maine took advantage of
the Maine State Planning Office sponsored two-day ADA workshops
held in October and November, 1996, in Auburn, Bangor and Gorham.
The workshops, primarily developed for the training and
certification of local enforcement officers and building
inspectors, were opened to design professionals and endorsed by
the Maine chapter of the AIA.
Developed and coordinated by architect Denis Pratt of Alpha
One, South Portland, Maine, workshop co-presenters included New
England ADA Technical Assistance Center training director Kathy
Gips and information specialists Kathleen Egan and Lisa Rouelle.
Donna Emerson, architect and fire protection specialist with the
Maine State Fire Marshal's Office also presented on life safety
issues and enforcement that affect accessibility compliance.
Informational presentations featured the newly enacted Maine
accessibility regulations that now incorporate Title III of the
ADA and the ADA Accessibility Guidelines. An advanced
"practical application" workshop is planned for the
fall of this year. For more information, contact Denis Pratt at
Alpha One, 207-767-2189.
Connecticut Conference of Municipalities (CCM) and the
State Office of Protection and Advocacy
Produce an ADA Newsletter for Connecticut cities and towns.
The winter 1997 issue highlights the work of New Haven ADA
Coordinator Sally Esposito and the participatory process that she
manages to update New Haven's Self Evaluation Plan. Ongoing
meetings provide an opportunity for each department to evaluate
its policies and practices. For a copy of the materials used in
the New Haven Self Evaluation Update, contact Cathy Erhardt at
CCM, 203-498-3042.
Back to top
GREAT WEB
SITES
National Council on Accessibility
www.indiana.edu/~nca/
This is a great web site with information on recreational
accessibility including golf courses, swimming pools and outdoor
trails.
National Park Service
www.nps.gov/
The state by state listing of parks provides brief access
information on each park.
U.S. Access Board
www.access_board.gov
Contains useful accessibility information about the ADA including
commonly asked questions and answers, and the Americans with
Disabilities Act Accessibility Guidelines (ADAAG).
Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC)
www.eeoc.gov
This is the long awaited site of the federal agency responsible
for enforcing the ADA employment regulations. It includes press
releases on new guidance as well as recent court decisions.
ADA-TA
www.icdi.wvu.edu/tech/ADA.HTM
A central web site with links to the ten Disability and Business
Technical Assistance Centers across the country, the ADA national
training projects, and disability related Federal Register
notices. (Note the correct address! Our apologies for omitting a
"dot" after wvu when we published this in our winter
issue.)
The New England ADA & Accessible IT Center
www.adaptiveenvironments.org
Our own site, with hot links to key federal ADA resources, New
England information, the ADA National Access to Public Schools
Project and universal design resources.
Back to top
FREQUENTLY ASKED
QUESTIONS
Specific ADAAG Questions
The following questions have been compiled by the Access Board
technical assistance staff. Visit their web-site at www.access_board.gov for
answers to other frequently asked questions.
Q:Are the mats placed on
the floor of my office lobby during wet weather considered carpet
that must be firmly attached? (ADAAG 4.3 Accessible route)
A: No, such mats are
"furnishings" not covered by ADAAG. However, section
36.211 of the Department of Justice rule requires that accessible
features be maintained so such furnishings cannot degrade the
accessible route. So-called "walk-off mats" are
designed to provide traction on wet floors and, as long as they
are stable and do not pose a tripping hazard, they may actually
improve the accessibility of a surface. On the other hand, loose
throw rugs, for example, could decrease the accessibility of a
surface.
Q: Is there a specific
coefficient of friction required for a surface to be "slip
resistant"? (ADAAG 4.5.1)
A: No. There are a
variety of ways to measure the coefficient of friction for
different materials and no single test device or procedure has
been identified. A Board sponsored research project, described in
the ADAAG Appendix Section A4.5.1, suggested some values but,
without a defined test procedure, these recommendations cannot be
applied.
Q: ADAAG specifies that
carpet must be firmly attached. Does this mean that each
individual carpet tile must by glued down? (ADAAG 4.5.3)
A: No. The requirement
is to ensure that the carpeted surface provides a firm and stable
surface. When carpet tiles are used, they are frequently
installed with some tiles glued down and others held in place by
friction. As long as the resulting carpeted surface remains firm
and stable, that is, the tiles don't move, the carpet is
considered to be firmly attached.
Q: Are curb ramps required
to have detectable warnings?
A: Not at the present
time. The requirements for detectable warnings on curb ramps, at
hazardous vehicular areas and at reflecting pools are suspended
until July 26, 1998. Detectable warnings are still required on
transit platform edges. (Formerly ADAAG 4.7.7)
Common Questions About Title II of the ADA
Q: Does a city have to provide curb ramps at every
intersection on existing streets?
A: No. To promote both
efficiency and accessibility, public entities may choose to
construct curb ramps at every point where a pedestrian walkway
intersects a curb, but they are not necessarily required to do
so. Alternative routes to buildings that make use of existing
curb cuts may be acceptable under the concept of program
accessibility in the limited circumstances where individuals with
disabilities need only travel a marginally longer route. In
addition, the fundamental alteration and undue burden limitations
may limit the number of curb ramps required. To achieve or
maintain program accessibility, it may be appropriate to
establish an ongoing procedure for installing curb ramps upon
request in areas frequented by individuals with disabilities as
residents, employees, or visitors. However, when streets, roads,
or highways are newly built or altered, they must have ramps or
sloped areas wherever there are curbs or other barriers to entry
from a sidewalk or path. Likewise, when new sidewalks or paths
are built or altered, they must contain curb ramps or sloped
areas wherever they intersect with streets, roads, or highways.
Resurfacing beyond normal maintenance is an alteration. Merely
filling potholes is considered to be normal maintenance.
The Title II questions were excerpted from a document
published by the Department of Justice's Public Access Section.
The full 6-page document is available from our Center by calling
800-949-4232 V/TTY.
And... here are some of the
frequently asked questions we've received from YOU. Call us for
answers!
* Must our town provide wheelchair access to an existing town
hall even though there is no one with a disability living here?
* I run a municipal recreation department summer camp; may I
require a parent to submit documentation regarding their child's
disability?
* May a physician's office or a municipality place a surcharge
on an individual to cover the cost of providing an interpreter?
* Is my historic property exempt from having to comply with
the ADA? Are any buildings "grandfathered"?
* I want to rent second-floor space for my business. Am I
required to install an elevator? What is the land lord required
to do? What about parking and rest rooms?
* Must my restaurant provide Braille menus to our customers?
* Must a municipal pool provide accessible locker rooms for
pool users?
* Is my employer required to provide me with an accessible
parking space?
Call 800-949-4232 for answers and guidance.
Back to top
PUBLICATIONS
Recommendations for Recreation and Outdoor Areas
This report from the Access Board presents the recommendations of
the Recreation Access Advisory Committee, and was published in
July, 1994. While the recommendations are neither proposed nor
final accessibility guidelines, they do represent the most
current comprehensive guidance available. Accessibility issues
addressed in the report are sports facilities, places of
amusement, play settings, golf courses, boating and fishing
facilities and outdoor developed areas. 201 pages, $2. A seven
page Executive Summary is available at no charge.
A Guide to Disability Rights Laws
This guide, produced in October of 1996 by the U.S. Department of
Justice, provides an overview of Federal civil rights laws that
ensure equal opportunity for people with disabilities. In
addition to the ADA, the guide covers the Fair Housing Act, the
Air Carrier Access Act, the Civil Rights of Institutionalized
Persons Act, the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, the
Rehabilitation Act and the Architectural Barriers Act. 14 pages,
no charge.
ADA Guide for Small Businesses
Written by the Department of Justice, this illustrated guide
presents an overview of some basic ADA requirements for small
businesses that provide goods and services to the public.
Numerous photographs and examples of barrier removal in the
following areas: parking, entrances, doors, turnstiles and
security gates, service counters, and fixed seating and tables.
The guide also contains guidance on communicating with customers
and information about available tax credits and deductions. 15
pages, no charge.
To order any of the above items, please call our Center at
800-949-4232 V/TTY. Or, you may e-mail to adaptive@adaptiveenvironments.org Be
sure to include a phone number and mailing address with e-mail
inquiries. Some shipping and handling charges may apply.
Materials are available in alternate formats upon request.
*Also Available...
Public Rights-of-Way Videos
The Access Board has recently released the first two of four
videos in its "Designing Accessible Sidewalks" series.
Produced for use by site, civil, and public works designers, the
videos provide valuable information that will aid engineers in
designing barrier-free sidewalks and street crossings for
pedestrians who are blind and pedestrians who use wheelchairs.
Each video is approximately ten minutes in length. Design
Issues for Pedestrians Who Use Wheelchairs, and, Design
Issues for Pedestrians Who Are Blind are now available from
the Access Board for use free by the public through a video loan
program. Individuals and organizations may make as many copies as
they wish before returning them. Limited quantities of the videos
are also available for purchase at $10 each. Requests should be
mailed to Lois Thibault, Training Coordinator, U.S. Access Board,
1331 F Street, NW, Suite 1000, Washington., DC 20004-1111.
Requests may also be sent via fax to: 202-272-5447 or e-mail: thibault@access_board.gov
(please include name, telephone number and full address).
Swimming Pool Accessibility Study
Recently completed for the Access Board by the National Center on
Accessibility (NCA), this report is the result of a national
research study on the means by which people with disabilities
access swimming pools. The Final Report is a comprehensive
document which includes a review of the literature, methods and
results from surveys of people with disabilities and aquatics
professionals, findings from pool testing of designs and devices
used for water entry, recommendations with supporting rationale
for providing pool access and product specifications. In addition
to the Final Report (366 pages; $25, plus shipping and handling),
the NCA is making available a condensed report, Recommendations
& Product Information, that is suggested for planners,
architects, engineers, aquatic directors, and pool managers, (88
pages; $7.50, plus shipping and handling) and an Executive
Summary, a brief, 7 page summary available at no cost. For copies
of any of these reports call the NCA at 800-424-1877 V/TTY or
contact their web-site at http://www.indiana.edu/~nca/
Back to top
EVENTS/
ANNOUNCEMENTS
Here are a few of the events scheduled around the region for
the spring. For a more comprehensive listing of ADA related
events, check the calendar at our web site, www.adaptiveenvironments.org
Assistive Technology '97 AT Work - AT School - AT Home - AT
Play
May 21, 1997 at the World Trade Center, Boston, MA Sponsored by
the Mass Assistive Technology Partnership Project. For
information 617-355-7820 Voice or 617-355-7301 TTY
Disabilities, Business and the Bottom Line
A conference for business owners, supervisors, personnel,
attorneys, and human service providers May 21, 1997 at the
Sheraton Conference Center, Burlington, VT. Sponsored by the
Vermont Association of Business, Industry & Rehabilitation
(VABIR) For information 802-655-7215 V/TTY
Cultural Access Institute
A national conference to support cultural access for people with
disabilities. Limited to pre-registered teams. May 27 - 30, 1997
at the Royal Sonesta Hotel, Boston, MA. Sponsored by Very Special
Arts Massachusetts in cooperation with the Mass Office on
Disability and the Mass Cultural Council For information
617-350-7713 V/TTY
ADA Conference
American Institute of Architects will hold an ADA conference in
Washington, DC, June 12 -13, 1997. For more information, contact
the AIA at 202 626 7300.
New England ADA & Accessible IT Center Training Events
In March, New England ADA & Accessible IT Center staff
participated in two days of in-depth Title 1 employment
discrimination training conducted by Sharon Rennert of the U.S.
Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. The training used the
case study method to analyze the following topics: reasonable
accommodation/undue hardship, definition of disability/mental
impairment, disability related questions/medical examinations,
definition of disability/regarded as substantially limited in
working, determining the essential functions of a position, and
direct threat. To spread the knowledge, Kathy Gips, Director of
Training, will be conducting five training sessions in June
throughout New England for people who provide technical
assistance or training on the ADA. For more information call
800-949-4232 V/TTY or 617-695-1225 ex. 23 V/TTY or KGips@adaptiveenvironments.org.
Back to top
Look for the summer issue of Access New England
focusing on public schools and our fall issue covering areas of
concern to employers and employees.
Moved recently? Changed your name? No longer interested in
receiving our newsletter? Let us know so we can keep our mailing
list up-to-date and effective. Call us at 800-949-4232 V/TTY,
e-mail us at adaptive@adaptiveenvironments.org
or drop us a line at 374 Congress Street, Suite 301, Boston, MA
02210.
Access New England is published quarterly by the New
England ADA Technical Assistance Center. The center is one of ten
Regional Disability and Business Technical Assistance Centers
funded by the National Institute on Disability and Rehabilitation
Research (NIDRR) to provide information, materials and technical
assistance to individuals and entities that are covered by the
Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). However, please be aware
the NIDRR is not responsible for enforcement of the ADA. The
information, materials and/or technical assistance are intended
solely as informal guidance and are neither a determination of
your legal responsibilities under the Act, nor binding on any
agency with enforcement responsibility under the ADA.
Access New England is available in large print, Braille, audio cassette,
and computer disk, upon request.
Back to Top
Back to Previous Page
|